Grace Evangelical Society

P.O. Box 1308, Denton, TX 76202
  • About
    • Home
    • Beliefs
    • Staff
    • Board of Directors
  • Resources
    • Grace in Focus Blog
    • Grace in Focus International Blogs
    • Grace in Focus Radio
    • Grace in Focus Magazine
    • Free eBooks
    • Journal of the GES
    • Book Reviews
    • Partners in Grace Newsletter
    • Audio Messages
    • Videos
    • Email Subscription
    • Bookstore
    • Online Tracts
  • Store
    • Main Page
    • On Sale
    • Return Policy
    • Your Cart
    • Your Account
  • Events
  • Connect
    • Contact Us
    • Free Grace Church and Bible Study Tracker
    • Free Grace Jobs
    • Ministry Links
  • Donate
    • One Time Donation
    • Monthly Donation
    • Your Account
  • Search
Home
→
Blog
→
Is John 7:53–8:11 Inspired Scripture?

Is John 7:53–8:11 Inspired Scripture?

October 5, 2018 by Bob Wilkin in Blog - John 7:53–8:11, Textual criticism, the woman caught in adultery

In the June 2018 edition of JETS (“The Pericope of the Woman Caught in Adultery: An Inspired Text Inserted into an Inspired Text?” pp. 321-37), Scott Kaczorowski makes an amazing suggestion about John 7:53–8:11.

Many have suggested that it is not part of John’s Gospel, but that it does represent an actual historical incident. Metzger’s Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament takes that position (pp. 187-89). So does Kaczorowski.

But Kaczorowski goes a step further. He says that while it does not belong in John’s Gospel, it is more than just an accurate historical account. He thinks that this account is actually “an inspired text” (pp. 321, 333-337).

I’ve long believed that the Majority Text (MT) carries the correct readings. Hence I’ve long believed that John 7:53–8:11 is inspired Scripture and that it belongs right there in John’s Gospel.

However, when I read Kaczorowski, I found myself wondering if I have forgotten the evidence. I then read Metzger’s comments in his Textual Commentary and realized I needed to go back and look at the evidence.

Hodges and Farstad have a long write up on this passage in their Greek New Testament According to the Majority Text (pp. xxiii-xxxii). Their explanation is night and day different than that of Kaczorowski and Metzger. They point out that over 900 manuscripts include this account and they give extensive evidence that the style is completely consistent with John’s style (contra Metzger and Kaczorowski).

The evidence is overwhelmingly in favor of John 7:53–8:11 being part of John’s Gospel.

Why is it, however, that Kaczorowski suggests that though he thinks this account was not part of John’s Gospel, it is inspired Scripture and should be taught in churches? He gives the following lines of evidence: 1) “Apostolicity and antiquity” (e.g., Papias in the late first and early second century attested to its authenticity, as did many of the church fathers), 2) “Historical authenticity and orthodoxy” (i.e., it was regarded as historical and there is nothing in it which is unorthodox), and 3) “Usage and spiritual power” (e.g., the church has always found this story to be very edifying).

Kaczorowski suggests this account is inspired Scripture. But without a home. It does not belong in John’s Gospel. Nor does it belong in any other book.

He seems fine with leaving it where it is in John’s Gospel, even though it does not belong there.

Why would God give us an account without a book? Is there anything else in the Bible which is inspired Scripture, but which does not belong in any book of the Bible?

I think Kaczorowski unwittingly makes a good case for John 7:53–8:11 being a part of John’s Gospel. In any case, I’m glad to see that he is convinced that it is part of inspired Scripture. This is a move in the right direction.

Subscribe by Email

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
Bob_W

by Bob Wilkin

Bob Wilkin (ThM, PhD, Dallas Theological Seminary) is the Founder and Executive Director of Grace Evangelical Society and co-host of Grace in Focus Radio. He lives in Highland Village, TX with his wife, Sharon. His latest books are Faith Alone in One Hundred Verses and Turn and Live: The Power of Repentance.

If you wish to ask a question about a given blog, email us your question at ges@faithalone.org.

Cart

Recently Added

February 1, 2023

Romans–Part 03–Wrath

Welcome to Grace in Focus radio. Today, Kathryn Wright and Ken Yates are continuing their discussion of the book of Romans. How is the book...
February 1, 2023

Being Honest with God (Ps 51:6)

The background to Psalm 51 is well-known. David had committed adultery and, as a result, murder, when he had Bathsheba’s husband killed. After some time,...
January 31, 2023

Romans–Part 02–Theme

Welcome to Grace in Focus radio. Today, Kathryn Wright, and Ken Yates continue their short introductory study of Romans. What is the theme and the...

Grace in Focus Radio

All Episodes

Listen to Stitcher

Listen on Spotify

Grace In Focus Magazine

Grace In Focus is sent to subscribers in the United States free of charge.

Subscribe for Free

The primary source of Grace Evangelical Society's funding is through charitable contributions. GES uses all contributions and proceeds from the sales of our resources to further the gospel of grace in the United States and abroad.

Donate

Bookstore Specials

  • Grudem Against Grace: A Defense of Free Grace Theology $15.00 $10.00
  • Here Walks My Enemy: The Story of Luis (Paperback) $6.95 $3.00
  • Here Walks My Enemy: The Story of Luis (Hardcover) $13.95 $5.00
  • The Journey of Faith $15.00 $9.00
  • Confident in Christ, 2nd Edition $22.00 $5.00
Grace Evangelical Society

(940) 270-8827 / ges@faithalone.org

4851 S I-35E Suite 203, Corinth, TX 76210
P.O. Box 1308, Denton, TX 76202

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube