Grace Evangelical Society

P.O. Box 1308, Denton, TX 76202
  • About
    • Home
    • Beliefs
    • Staff
    • Board of Directors
  • Resources
    • Grace in Focus Blog
    • Grace in Focus International Blogs
    • Grace in Focus Radio
    • Grace in Focus Magazine
    • Free eBooks
    • Journal of the GES
    • Book Reviews
    • Partners in Grace Newsletter
    • Audio Messages
    • Videos
    • Email Subscription
    • Bookstore
    • Online Tracts
  • Store
    • Main Page
    • On Sale
    • Return Policy
    • Your Cart
    • Your Account
  • Events
  • Seminary
    • Seminary Info
    • Fall 2023 Classes
    • GES Seminary Curriculum
    • GES Seminary Faculty
  • Connect
    • Contact Us
    • Free Grace Church and Bible Study Tracker
    • Free Grace Jobs
    • Ministry Links
  • Donate
    • One Time Donation
    • Monthly Donation
    • Your Account
  • Search
Home
→
Journal Articles
→
Book Reviews
→
A Layman’s Guide to the Lordship Controversy

A Layman’s Guide to the Lordship Controversy

Posted in Book Reviews

A Layman’s Guide to the Lordship Controversy. By Richard P. Belcher. Southbridge, MA: Crowne Publications, 1990. 123 pp. Paper, $6.95.

On the surface, this book promises the layman a grasp of the Lordship Salvation controversy. What will quickly grasp the uninformed layman, however, is a limited presentation of the Lordship Salvation debate and thus a skewed understanding of the real issues.

The title of this book promises an objective presentation of both the Lordship Salvation and Free Grace positions. This it does to a limited degree. The book would better be titled, “A Layman’s Guide to the John MacArthur—Zane Hodges Controversy,” for these are virtually the only two men he chooses to represent. The great weakness of the book is that Belcher does not realize or admit that the Free Grace position has one theology which encompasses different interpretations consistent with that theology. He never cites any Free Grace advocate other than Hodges, not even Charles C. Ryrie (mentioned only in passing). Ryrie’s book So Great Salvation was also a response to MacArthur. Evidently, Belcher hasn’t interacted with any copies of the Journal of the Grace Evangelical Societyeither! In a phone conversation, the author told me that he chose to represent only Hodges because his book, Absolutely Free!, was the most controversial, was most often contrasted with MacArthur’s by laymen, and was better systematized than Ryrie’s. This is not enough to convince me that Belcher has treated the Free Grace position with objectivity.

Although the title and introduction claim to represent both sides objectively, the reader quickly perceives that Belcher is not so objective after all. (He does not admit that he supports MacArthur’s position until his conclusion, pp. 105–106.) The first two sections present and contrast MacArthur’s views and Hodges’s views somewhat fairly (though he prefers the term “non-lordship”, while we prefer “Free Grace”—a hint of bias to come). However, the five specific interpretations by Hodges that he critiques seem chosen arbitrarily or because they represent very controversial viewpoints (Jas 2:14–26; Rom 10:9–13; 2 Cor 13:5; Rom 8:17; 1 Cor 6:9–10).

Thus from the outset, the book appears on a mission to discredit the Free Grace view as a “new view of salvation” (p. 83). By the time the third section is reached (“A Critique of Non-Lordship Salvation”), the book assumes an acrimonious air. Discussion of Scripture passages is superficial or neglected. This is to be regretted because Hodges’s exegesis and research should be answered with comparable exegesis and research, or opponents should be silent.

Belcher chooses to argue rhetorically and theologically, yet he fails to avoid dogmatism. Also, “straw men” (a favorite term of his) are erected in his chapter on “Theological Weaknesses of Non-lordship Salvation” (I counted six straw men out of the eight representations of the Free Grace position).

The book is long on rhetoric and short on the kind of critical interaction that is needed in the debate. I fear that it will guide laymen, but only in the wrong direction, and that it will inflame rather than inform. Belcher should have taken the time to acquaint himself with other interpretations that represent the Free Grace position and to have made the effort to answer the more serious theological issues at the heart of the Lordship Salvation debate.

Charles C. Bing
Editorial Board
Journal of the Grace Evangelical Society
Burleson, TX

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Cart

Recently Added

September 28, 2023

What Is Christ’s Kingdom and Kingdom Parables?

Welcome to Grace in Focus radio! Today, Bob Wilkin and Steve Elkins are beginning a short series about kingdom parables. How should we think about...
September 28, 2023

Do We Have to Wait Till We Die to Get Everlasting Life?

G. C. asks a great question: I appreciate your ministry. I am in a discussion with a man in our church who insists that Jesus...
September 27, 2023

Is Believing Jesus Has the Power to Save Us the Same as Believing in Him For Everlasting Life?

Welcome to Grace in Focus radio! Today, Bob Wilkin and Ken Yates are answering a question about the saving message and about saving faith. What...

Grace in Focus Radio

All Episodes

Listen on Google Podcasts

Listen on Spotify

Grace In Focus Magazine

Grace In Focus is sent to subscribers in the United States free of charge.

Subscribe for Free

The primary source of Grace Evangelical Society's funding is through charitable contributions. GES uses all contributions and proceeds from the sales of our resources to further the gospel of grace in the United States and abroad.

Donate

Bookstore Specials

  • Here Walks My Enemy: The Story of Luis (Hardcover) $13.95 $5.00
  • Elisabeth: Christ's Medal of Honor Recipient $11.95 $10.00
  • The Gospel Under Siege: Faith and Works in Tension $15.00 $10.00
  • Six Secrets of the Christian Life (Second Edition, Includes Study Questions) $6.00 $4.00
  • Faith Alone in One Hundred Verses $15.00 $10.00
Grace Evangelical Society

(940) 270-8827 / ges@faithalone.org

4851 S I-35E Suite 203, Corinth, TX 76210
P.O. Box 1308, Denton, TX 76202

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube